I’m so excited to introduce Margie Lawson as our month-long January guest at Routines for Writers. Her bio is below, but let me just tell you she is a friend to writers! She is an energetic and encouraging teacher. If you take her advice, you will be amazed at how much better your writing will be. Good news: she also loves a good contest. She’s running one for us today, and if you check out her website you’ll see she’s got an even bigger one going there! Let’s have fun, and learn together this month.
A writer strives to select every word to build momentum. The perfect words create page turners.
Every word counts. Writers can’t allow lazy words to add weight to their work. No slackers!
Audition your words.
Hold each word up and evaluate it. Be sure it’s a keeper.
Imagine a word line stretching from New York City to San Francisco. Picture each word of your book strung on that line. It’s your job to push a ladder cross country those 2909 miles, step by step, hooking every letter to the word line.
Each word that’s the perfect fit has a quality that’s magical. When you hook the last letter of the word, an invisible force keeps those letters from adding weight to the word line. If the word works, its weight is self-supporting.
The magic works both ways. If these words become superfluous based on subsequent words added to the line, they lose their power and add weight, creating sag.
Extraneous words, tautologies, unnecessary phrases, echoes, excessive description, fluffy dialogue, vague and wasted words—all become as heavy as tombstones. Tombstones weigh down your line and run your story into the dirt. Your word line may stretch from New York City to Newark above ground, then go subterranean.
Books with few wasted words allow the reader to zip along the word line on a smooth trip from New York City to San Francisco. That’s a compelling read.
We’ve all read books that start strong and fresh and draw us through the first few chapters or maybe the first third of the book, then BLAUGH. Something doesn’t work.
We put the book down and forget to pick it up for days. When we return to the story, we can’t remember the story.
If the reader can abandon those characters for days and not recall what’s happening, either the plot is plodding or the craft of writing is as burdensome and arduous as climbing Mount Everest.
Without oxygen.
In that can-put-it-down book—the snoozer—what writing craft changes would have made it an irresistible read?
1) Getting input from a strong Critique Partner.
2) Writing tight – nixing unnecessary words and phrases
3) Writing fresh – including fresh body language and dialogue cues and fresh visceral emotion.
4) Analyzing scenes with the EDITS System.
5) Using a wide range of rhetorical devices.
6) Practicing Deep Editing – including my 5 Question Scene Check List
Let’s look at items one and two.
1. Getting input from a Strong Critique Partner.
Writers frequently use the phrase, TIGHTEN, when critiquing other’s work. It’s so easy to see the flab in someone else’s work. Not so easy when it’s the words you may have struggled through hours of labor to deliver.
What does tighten mean? If a critique partner brackets half of one of your pages and scribbles TIGHTEN in the margin, there are multiple interpretations.
Is the passage too slow? Do you need to keep the length, but make it more active?
Is it too long?
Is there too much description? Too much dialogue? Too much dreck?
Did you meander? Follow a tangent? Does the tangent need to be cut, or just parts of it?
Does the passage need to be cut by 10%? 25%? 50%? 95%?
Is tightening enough? If tightened, would the passage soar?
Are there any lines that absolutely don’t work and others that are winners?
How invested is the critiquer in having you tighten this section?
When critiquing, it’s helpful to provide as much input as possible. Take a few extra seconds and share WHY something works when you compliment their work.
– Great simile!
– Fresh writing.
– Love how you added power with anaphora!
On the flip side, you can also add information when you share YOUR TAKE on why something doesn’t work. You may share notes like this:
–Dragging. Too many internalizations?. Tighten by 30%? Break it up by inserting some of your dialogue here? Or add a Dialogue Cue?
– Light on setting . . .
–Vary sentence structure?
–Backload?
–Choppy. For me – it’s too many short sentences in a row.
–Great visceral, but I think you need more. Maybe add a hit of Internalization (YELLOW) to support the visceral (PINK) – then add another line of visceral (PINK) after the internalization (YELLOW).
Those comments are nudges. Gentle suggestions.
One of the bonuses of DEEP EDITING someone else’s work is that you learn more.
By being a strong EDITING PARTNER –you’ll be a better writer.
2. Writing Tight
Echo words and phrases become cognitive trip-wires. The reader has a blip in their reading, not a fall-on-your-face speed-bump, but a stumble. I think of it as a synapse pause.
It pays to review for echo words. Each writer looks for their favorite words. They could be all forms of words like grab, grip, glance, look, see, lean, tug, pull, cross, tap, turn . . .
The FIND function in your WORD program may become your best friend. I recommend keeping a list of your FREQUENTLY USED WORDS and do a FIND on them after every chapter, from page 1 through your current page. Add to your list.
Using the FIND function is also a great way to track which facial expressions and dialogue cues you use frequently—which gives you a chance to expand your repertoire and provide more fresh writing. If you do a FIND for EYES and get lots of hits, and do a FIND on MOUTH and LIPS and get none or few—that’s good information. You know what you need to do. Nix some eyes. Add more mouth and lip responses. And write them all fresh.
Think of the ways you typically share physical emotion and do a FIND on the key words. You’ll know what you have, where, and decide which you need to rewrite.
I’ll be back next Tuesday to share more secrets of writing irresistible fiction. Now it’s your turn.
PLEASE CHIME IN!
POST A COMMENT – AND YOU MAY WIN A LECTURE PACKET!
I will draw a name for a Lecture Packet, a $22 value, at 8PM Mountain Time. Winners may choose a Lecture Packet from one of my six on-line courses. Lecture Packets are available for all my courses through Paypal from my website, www.MargieLawson.com.
1. Empowering Characters’ Emotions
2. Deep Editing: The EDITS System, Rhetorical Devices, and More
3. Writing Body Language and Dialogue Cues Like a Psychologist
4. Powering Up Body Language in Real Life: Projecting a Professional Persona When Pitching and Presenting
5. Digging Deep into the EDITS System
6. Defeat Self-Defeating Behaviors
Margie Lawson —psychotherapist, writer, and international presenter—developed innovative editing systems and deep editing techniques for writers.
Her Deep Editing tools are used by all writers, from newbies to NYT Bestsellers. She teaches writers how to edit for psychological power, how to hook the reader viscerally, how to create a page-turner.
Over four thousand writers have learned Margie’s psychologically-based deep editing material. In the last five years, she presented fifty-two full day Master Classes for writers in the U.S., Canada, Australia, and New Zealand.
Lectures from each of Margie’s on-line courses are offered as Lecture Packets through PayPal from her web site. For more information on courses, lecture packets, master classes, and 3-day Immersion Master Class sessions, visit: www.MargieLawson.com .
Thank you for joining us today!
All smiles…………Margie
www.MargieLawson.com

Related Articles
23 users responded in this post
I definitely find that I repeat myself in my writing…a lot. Vocabulary has never been my “thing” so using new, more exciting words, especially verbs, is something I definitely need to work on.
Thank you so much for your insight today, Margie! I look forward to your future posts!
Stormy –
Thanks for chiming in!
Most writers are challenged when it comes to writing fresh body language and dialogue cues. Cliched lines invite skimming.
I’d love to see some great examples of facial expressions and dialogue cues posted on Routines for Writers this month.
)
I’m at work today. I’ll pop back on-line late this afternoon. I live in Denver. My 4PM is 6PM on the east coast.
All smiles………..Margie
http://www.MargieLawson.com
Margie, I think your comment, “Is tightening enough? If tightened, would the passage soar?, resonated with me today. As a former newspaper reporter, I sometimes err on the side of conciseness. I need to actually step away and add some flesh to the bones, rather than take away!
Great timing for a great topic. Just last night one of my critique partners and I met with a fellow writer who is currently partnerless, and we couldn’t stress enough the value of our critique group. In a solitary profession, just meeting with other writers who understand your life is beneficial. In a profession riddled with criticism and rejection, a strong critique partner or group who provide constructive guidance makes a world of difference. There is so much to know, no one person can be an expert on all aspects of writing. In my group, there are four of us, we have different styles, different perspectives, different strengths and write different in genres. Together we are invincible.
I’m guilty of the “too long” and “run on” sentence. I have a very patient critique partner that calls me on it.
I’ve been reading body language books trying to broaden expression beyong she bit her bottom lip *g*
Will definitely be back next Tuesday.
Hi Margie!
You are so right about the power of a good critique partner, and about being specific when possible. I think the same should be said for judging contests. If you’re taking the time to judge, you should give as much feedback as possible.
Hi Margie,
The Find button is definitely my friend. I always do a search for words like just, almost, eyes, gaze etc. and always find that I have too many of them diluting my writing.
Great article.
Sri.
Hi Margie,
Great post! I find editing to be the most fascinating part of writing. There’s just something about spit-polishing that gets my heart pumping! I’m glad I found your site. I’ll be visiting often.
Blessings,
Joanne
Hi, Margie, great post!
I think time/distance are our friends when writing. When finishing a project you’re simply too close to the words to know how much is enough versus how much is too much. Time away from the project and a good critique partner’s fresh take are invaluable when you go back through your work to edit.
Kay
Hi Margie,
I completly agree with your comments on getting a critique partner, and getting them to give you the information that you need. I love getting feedback, both good and bad since it really shows me different perspectives that I may never have come up with on my own.
I am making notes of your questions to ask critiquers though!
-Courtney
Hi Margie,
Thanks for the great tips! I belong to a critique chapter (Chicago-North RWA), but it’s helpful to see new ways of providing useful feedback. Writing tight is probably my biggest issue. I find a word I like then use it again, and again, and again. . .within the same couple of pages! I will definitely try using the Find function in Word. :0)
Laurie
Margie!
Ah, more brilliance spews from your fingertips and into our eyes… which sounds like you are flinging hot coffee at my face…
Your inspiring words and excitement are always welcome and I love reading anything you have to say! I look forward to more insight from you in your lecture packets and the DSDB class!
Claire L. Fishback
Hi, Margie.
I have come to appreciate the value of a Strong critique partner, from both sides of the paper. A partner who provides more than just ‘you have a lot of words here’. A partner who is specific. A partner who explains what is meant by ‘tighten’.
It might have saved me several years of making the same mistakes repeatedly. And wearing out a few ‘dog leashes’ thinking that minute details of activity equates with ’show’.
Your courses, and course alumns, have been one of my best writing investments. Thanks for your insights.
Eleyne
Hi Margie,
Thanks for your comments and may your new year be filled with blessings!
I always love your blogs as classes, they are great refreshers as well as offer excellent insight. My favorite phrase of your blog, “Each word that’s the perfect fit has a quality that’s magical.” Exactly. And when you hit that magical word, the one that takes your sentence up to the next level, you can ‘feel’ the magic of that word. It’s flat out amazing. At times I even shiver.
Sincerely,
Diana Cosby
Romance Edged With Danger
Hi, Margie! Great reminders. I’m guilty of overwriting my scenes, so “tighten” is something I hear a lot from my crit group.
But I’m going to include your suggestions for more specific feedback at our next meeting, as that would be a great deal more useful for all of us, whether we’re having our work examined or performing the critique. Thank you! And see you in class this month.
Chassily
I really need to take the deep edits class, I find I am doing it in bits and pieces. I absolutely agree you need a good critique partner..someone truthful.
Now, I have to go slay some defeating behaviors in your class Margie!
Cheers!
M.V.
Hello Everyone!
So cool to see so many soon-to-be dragon-slayers from Defeat Self-Defeating Behaviors class. Thanks for dropping by ROUTINES FOR WRITERS!
Sherry — I misread your word: partnerless. I read pantless.
Chassily — Great plan to encourage critique groups to give more specific feedback. Sometimes the critiquer knows a line or paragraph or page or scene (or chapter!) doesn’t work, but doesn’t know why. Perfect opp to toss it out to the group.
I bet you all do that. I’m just yammering here.
)
No time for me to respond to everyone who posted today. Wish I could! But I’m still in downtown Denver (from work) and have to drive an hour to get up the mountain to my home — and respond to my on-line class e-mails.
I’ll draw a name for the winner of the Lecture Packet about 9PM Mountain Time.
See you soon!
All smiles………..Margie
Hi Margie!
Thanks so much for joining us this month at Routines for Writers! The three of us have been so excited for weeks since we’ve each taken at least one class or bought at least one lecture. In fact, when I moved from CA to Sydney, I put my ms that I’d started doing Deep Edits on, as well as all my colored highlighters, in my suitcase! I didn’t want to wait until our household goods arrived two months later! LOL!
Can’t wait to read your next post!
Love, Kitty
Thoroughly enjoyed your post. Looking forward to learning lots in your DSB course on WritU.
Margie–Loved the frequently used word section. I so love “then” and “turned toward.” I’ll definitely give that find key a workout now. Looking forward to your help with my SDBs.
Theresa
Hello Everyone!
I decided to draw TWO NAMES!
The two winners are ELEYNE and CHASSILY!
Eleyne and Chassily: Please contact me and let me know which of my six Lecture Packets you would like. I’ll send the lectures to you as e-mail attachments.
Margie@MargieLawson.com
A BIG THANK YOU — to SHONNA and STEPHANIE and KITTY for inviting me to spend the month at ROUTINES FOR WRITERS!
Next Tuesday, I’m cracking my Deep Editing whip. You will learn how to dig deep and write body language and dialogue cues. FRESH.
)
See you next week!
All smiles……….Margie
HELLO —
I have to tell you all about my DAREDEVIL DACHSHUND CONTEST!
It’s my way of having fun with you on my web site. It’s also another way I can give back, by awarding a packet of cool prizes to a dozen writers a year.
Think ‘Where’s Waldo?’ with two cartoon miniature dachshunds.
On the first day of each month, I’ll place a cartoon dachshund on one of my web site pages.
You find the DareDevil Dachshund, e-mail me with the name of the page it’s on, and you will be entered in the monthly drawing. You could win my EDITS System Power Pack!
The EDITS System Power Pack includes a certificate for one hour of my Deep Editing brain.
Interested?
The January contest runs through January 26th. Check it out: http://www.MargieLawson.com
All smiles………..Margie
Awesome contest, Margie! What a brilliant way to get everyone to click through your web site. Even though I’ve been there a few times, I’ve never clicked on all the pages before today. Thanks for letting everyone know!
Leave A Reply