I spend a lot of time talking to writers about books and writing. I can get on a Skype chat with Kitty and Stephanie and we can spend many happy hours discussing the finer things of plot points and voice and character arcs.
But when my husband is having trouble falling asleep he asks me to talk about writing. It started off as a joke, but in reality, talking about the latest behind-the-scenes YA controversy puts him under like nothing else.
Last year I signed up for a book club and I’m the only writer in the bunch. I also belong to a large homeschool support group, and if you know anything about homeschoolers, you know they love books.
I’ve been noticing some similarities, but more interesting to me, differences among my writer friends and my reader friends.
Readers aren’t that interested in the behind-the-scenes stuff. The odd tidbit here and there they find interesting, but if you talk too much, their eyes tend to glaze over. One example, at my last book club meeting we were reading The Yada Yada Prayer Group by Neta Jackson. I just so happened to have a copy of the BOOK PROPOSAL that sold the book. (Don’t ask me how I got it…don’t remember, it’s just one of those things that I picked up somewhere!)
No one wanted a copy. No one even wanted to take home the copy I brought. My reader friends thought various parts were interesting and it provided additional information for our discussions (like the meanings of the character’s names). But that was it. Had this been a group of writers, we would have been making photocopies and spending the rest of the evening analyzing it.
Readers are intensely loyal to their favorite authors. Even when those authors bomb. In book club we were reading one book that I could not even finish. This was a book that appeared to be pushed through the pipeline at the last minute. The writing was poor, the editing was poor. I wasn’t the only one who found editing mistakes—content editing mistakes—not just a missing comma or a misspelled word. But the author has written a ton of books. We all made excuses for this particular book and assured each other that her others were better. (I have to admit I really like this trait in readers. Grace when we happened to slip up is a good thing.)
Readers know when a book works. (And when it doesn’t work!) They may not know all the ins and outs on why it works, but the good books stand out and make readers happy. Very happy.
Parents DO care what their children read. They wish that authors would support the morals they are trying to instill in their kids. I learned this both from book club and from my homeschool group. One of the ladies I know whose granddaughter, a teenager, is struggling with all that teenage angst, made the comment that “there is just no support” meaning, she was feeling the culture pressing back on everything she was trying to help her granddaughter navigate. She was talking about more than just books—movies, TV shows, clothing, etc. But you get the gist. Another mom wrote to our email loop asking for book suggestions for her daughter. She said she and her newly 13-year old daughter went to the YA section at the library and she “just about had a heart attack” when she saw the books available in the youth section.
Characters are real to readers, too! The gals in my book club talk about characters like they are living people with histories (backstory!) and hopes and dreams (motivation!). However, readers talk about character in a slightly different way that writers do. I’m still trying to put this nuance into words, because it is so slight and when I think about it, the thought slips away. It may only be the difference of coming at a character from the back end (deconstruction) VS the front end (construction.) Whatever it is, I’m learning a lot about effective character development by just sitting back and listening in book club.
In all, I love how enthusiastic readers are. They love books as much as writers do and that’s a great thing!



